« You Get to Choose the Conversation About You | Main | Are Dads a New Market Opportunity? »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c03bb53ef0148c85f92d4970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Role of Curation in Developing and Transmitting News:

Comments

Niall Harbison

We really live in a time when we 100% need more curation and I think that for it to be most effective it will have to be done by humans. There is a certain amount that can be done with filters and customized news etc but I always find I miss some good information if I rely on that method alone.

MarcFuseki

Very interesting post!

People have been selecting, organizing and sharing information pretty much since information existed. We started to call it curation when we realized that less is more, that it was time to address information overload. As a natual consequence, curation tools of the first generation are filters: their mission is to facilitate the processing of inbound streams of information.

Curation tools of the next generation are using curation as a mean of expression: by selecting their "best of the web", by adding context and a personal touch to it, curators engage with their audience, they create outbound, interactive streams of information. So I definitively agree with your statement: "You can indeed curate and transmit news in novel ways".

(note: I'm a founder of Scoop.it, a publish-by-curation platform)

Valeria Maltoni

And the filters may change over time, too. For example, I revisit my Google Reader monthly to recalibrate whether the blogs and publications I syndicate are giving me the information I need to continue to learn, etc.

Valeria Maltoni

Welcome to the conversation, Marc. Curation is a skill that goes beyond what modern tools provide. There are so many who set up sites to just grab the RSS of blogs and republish; and bookmarklets make that easy. If you asked those people, they'd probably tell you they "curate" their social presences by selecting the best posts, when all they do is scrape content by others. A generation of tools that encourages original thought, citations vs. scraping or reposting, would be a step in the right directions. Early days indeed.

MarcFuseki

Thank you Valeria. Cannot agree more, on both points: curation is a skill (hence, a human commitment, not any type of machine magic) and tools still have a long way to go.

We at Scoop.it consider the curator as an Editor in chief. The tool suggests content (by searching the social web) but, upon "scooping" a content, the curator is invited to edit it, to add value to it.

At the end of the day, a good tool should make it easy to find relevant content and to organize it in a personal way, but good curations come only from good curators.

Please let me know if you are interested to try Scoop.it (we are private beta - early days :)), I'd be delighted to have your feed back, since I believe we agree on the mission :)

Valeria Maltoni

@Marc -- so far, the users I have seen have simply taken my content and that of others, not just the links... which to me is the anti-curation movement. No original thought added, just a clip of my post in some other guy's front page. How is that adding value?

MarcFuseki

@Valeria,

To answer your question, I agree that a mere collection of clips is not a good curation (although identifying good content out of the information overload has value, one could claim). The curator selects content, of course, but then can add his personal touch: contextualization, comment, organization, etc. The mission of a good curation tool is to make this easy. Admittedly, some curators are actually just bookmarking. But I believe good curators will emerge and will gain reputation, based on their selection of content and also on their personal style.

twitter.com/wmougayar

Yes, curation is important for news, but curation should be seen as a means to an end, not the end itself. It's currently probably one of the most used, misused and abused words in the context of social media. But curation isn't entirely dependent on social media, although it's a part of it. Content/news curation has been around for a long time before social media. Social media and the real-time web amplify the news. Curation gives it another twist.

The comments to this entry are closed.

be your own boss

Outposts

About You


Conversations


Comment Policy

  • This is my blog and not a public space. Critical discourse is welcomed. I will, however, delete your comment if you descend into personal attacks, inappropriate language, disrespectful behavior, or excessive self-promotion and link-baiting.

Book Reviews


Disclaimer

  • The opinions blogged herein represent only those of Valeria Maltoni and do not reflect those of her employer, persons or companies mentioned herein, or anyone else.

© Valeria Maltoni

  • Creative Commons License


  • Conversation AgentTM

  • © 2006-2012 Valeria Maltoni. All rights reserved.

Subscribe

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Search

Sponsorship opportunities

Marketing that makes business sense


Advisory Boards


As seen on

Conversation Agent on Facebook